FROM MY FARMSTAND KITCHEN TO YOURS

Birthday Cake Cookies

By Kelli Bowman

Jump to recipe

Soft, buttery cookies bursting with colorful sprinkles and classic birthday cake flavor. Sweet, festive, and baked to perfection, these cookies bring the fun and nostalgia of birthday cake to every bite.

Loading recipe…

Questions & Comments

    1. I don’t have a peanut butter cookie recipe on my website yet, but it’s something I may have to add in the future!

    1. This powdered sugar icing should firm up as it dries, but it won’t harden quite like royal icing. I’d recommend letting the cookies sit uncovered until the icing is completely dry before stacking. You can also place parchment paper between layers to prevent sticking.

    1. You could try vanilla extract instead! It won’t have quite the same buttery flavor, but it should still be delicious.

  1. Hi Kelli, can we make all the balls and freeze them until birthday, then bake? Bring to room temp or bake from frozen?

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Comments are reviewed before appearing on the site. Required fields are marked *.

Search recipes, baking tips, and farmstand stories.