Cookie Recipes
FROM MY FARMSTAND KITCHEN TO YOURS
By Kelli Bowman
Jump to recipeThese rich, bakery-style cookies combine nutty browned butter with gooey chocolate chips and crunchy toffee pieces for the perfect balance of soft, chewy, and crisp textures. With deep caramel notes and a hint of coffee to enhance the flavor, they’re an indulgent, crowd-favorite cookie.
Loading recipe…
Hi, can you please send me your toffee recipe? It looks delish!!
I love your videos!!
Thank you!
Thank you! You can find my Homemade Toffee recipe linked in this recipe or by searching Homemade Toffee on my website!
is there a recipe for the homemade toffee pieces
It’s on her website if you do a search.
Hi, i found the recipe for toffee pieces that she added to the cookie https://stablesidefarmstand.com/recipe-box/homemade-toffee/?rq=toffee
Hey Kelli! I love your videos on Instagram! How do you make your toffee bits. I couldn’t fond the recipe but I may be looking in the wrong place!
Tips for freezing the dough and baking? I love your Facebook page. I find it very soothing to watch you bake and prepare all your yummy baked goods. Thankyou for sharing!!!
Thank you so much! I recommend chilling the dough for 24 hours, then scooping and freezing the dough balls in an airtight container. You can bake them straight from frozen, just add a few extra minutes to the baking time!
Thank you so much for sharing your recipes. They all look delicious and I can’t wait to try them. I love to bake but am not confident enough in my skills to create my own recipes! I was wondering if you usually measure or weigh your ingredients? Do you have the weights for your recipes? Your toffee chocolate chip one in particular. Thank you so much!!
Thank you so much! I typically measure my ingredients using cups rather than weighing them, so I don’t have gram measurements for all my recipes.
Hi
In the video you said baking powder but the recipe above says baking soda. Thanks for your time
Baking soda is correct! I may have misspoken in the video, but the recipe on my website has the correct ingredients.
Love the taste of the toffee chocolate chip cookies! I’m struggling with having the toffee run all over the pan when they’re baked. I’ve tried putting them in an upright “egg”, lowering the temp to 350, cooking from frozen, baking on parchment paper, and cooking less time. I still get about half of them spread out all over the pan. The only way to fix it is to use a mug and swish it around. What am I doing wrong? Is it my toffee? My family LOVES these so I want to perfect them! Thanks!!
I’m so glad your family loves them! It could be the toffee melting and spreading during baking, especially if larger pieces are near the edges of the dough. Try breaking the toffee into smaller pieces and keeping them tucked inside the dough balls rather than on the outside. I’d also stick with 375°F.
I love the taste of these, but mine are big and puffy, not flat and pretty like yours, what did I do wrong? 😑
I’m so glad you love the flavor! Puffy cookies can sometimes be caused by too much flour. Be sure to fluff your flour, spoon it into the measuring cup, and level it off without packing it down.
These cookies sounds amazing. Would love to make them but I don’t see the toffee recipe link below like it says
What brand of chocolate do you use for chocolate chip toffee cookies? I made 8 sticks of brown butter and your toffee yesterday. So just measure out one cup brown butter for 1 batch?
I use a combination of milk, semi-sweet, and dark chocolate chips! And yes, since you’ve already browned your butter, just measure out 1 cup for this recipe!
Are they chunks or chips of chocolate?
I use a combination of chocolate chips and chunks!
Hay everyone, Kelli has made it so simple and I keep seeing the same question about the toffee. Have any of you checked her website before asking the questions. She literally has her recipes on there. Like all of them. I get it everyone wants all the answers and believe it or not they are there you just have to look. Make sure to use the search bar before you go through all the pages or say you can’t find something. Happy Baking
Thank you so much for your support! I appreciate you helping others find their way around the website and recipes!
These were amazing! I substituted some espresso powder and hot water for the coffee
Only two problems:
A lot of the toffee leaked out of some of the cookies and pooled on the baking sheet making a bit of a burnt mess. Open to suggestions to deal with that if making them again
Other problem is they went so fast I only got to try one!
I’m so glad they were a hit! Try breaking the toffee into smaller pieces and keeping them tucked inside the dough rather than near the edges. That should help prevent some of the leaking. Sounds like you’ll need a double batch next time!
Hi, Kelli. Thanks for all of the great recipes. Since browning butter removes the liquid, do we need to brown more than a cup of butter, or is the coffee replacing the lost water? Thanks again.
Thank you so much! You’ll want 1 cup of finished browned butter, so you’ll need to start with a little more than 1 cup. The coffee helps replace the moisture lost during browning!
Do you have a recommendation for the weight of each cookie dough ball? I typically weigh out all my ingredients.
Thank you!
I do about 120g
What brand and type of flaked salt do you use? I have four kinds and none of them are big enough flakes?,
I use Maldon Sea Salt Flakes! They have those beautiful, large, flaky crystals that are perfect for finishing cookies and other baked goods!
What type of Sea Flakes do you use for the topping? I have no success after trying 4 kinds – they are all too small. Thanks, SJ
I use Maldon Sea Salt Flakes! They have those beautiful, large, flaky crystals that are perfect for finishing cookies and other baked goods!
Hi. How many cookies does this recipe make?
14-16 depending on how large you scoop them! I use about 1/4 c size (scoop size 16) and get 14
Hi Kelli! I was hoping you could clarify something about the butter in your Toffee Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe.
The recipe calls for 210 g of browned butter, When I made it, I actually needed to start with approximately 255 g (about 1⅛ cups) of regular butter to end up with 210 g of browned butter (about ¾ cup plus 1½ tbsp).
Should we be using exactly 210 g of finished browned butter, or should we simply start with 1 cup (227 g) of regular butter and use whatever remains after browning?
Also, if we’re using exactly 210 g of finished browned butter, should we still add the 3 tablespoons (44 ml) of brewed coffee or water? I’m wondering whether that’s intended to replace moisture lost during browning or is an additional ingredient regardless of the final butter weight.
I’d really appreciate your clarification. Thank you so much!
If subbing a recipe for brown butter that calls for regular butter you will always have to brown extra as you are making up for the lost liquid and need to add extra in when browning. My cookie recipe is already formulated with brown butter and the liquid you need so no substitutions are needed for that recipe!
Hi! For step 1, if I already made the brown butter, am I just measuring and adding? Or am I supposed to reheat the brown butter that I already made until foamy?
If you’ve already made your browned butter, you can skip the browning step! Just measure out 1 cup of finished browned butter and use it at room temperature. No need to heat it until foamy again!
Do I need to freeze or can I just bake once dough is made
You don’t need to freeze the dough! I recommend chilling it for 24 hours before baking. This helps develop the flavor and keeps the cookies from spreading too much. I usually bake mine right after chilling!
hi! love your channel and content! WHen I cooked these, they browned awfully fast and like others, the toffee leaked out on some. I did try to tuck it in the middle.
But they definitely came out too dark. wondering if maybe for my oven (runs normal as I have checked with thermometer in past) I should use 350. They tasted great, but I wanted to sell in my ice cream shop and they were way too dark. Thanks!
Thank you so much! Yes, I’d definitely try baking at 350°F if they’re browning too quickly in your oven. You may need to add a few minutes to the baking time. For the toffee, try using smaller pieces and keeping them tucked well inside the dough. I’d recommend testing a small batch to find what works best for your oven!
In the FB video I saw a sheet tray of browned butter. For large batch baking, do you brown the butter in a large pot and just cool it on a tray or is there a magic oven-made browned butter technique I don’t know about?
There is an oven method! I actually brown large batches of butter right on rimmed sheet pans in the oven. I stir occasionally and keep a close eye on it until it’s golden brown and smells nutty. It’s such a time-saver for large batch baking!
Hi kara, I followed your exact recipe step by step. I was a bit skeptical about 16 mins in the oven at 375 but did it anyways,
When they came out they were dark brown, not burnt but def should not have come out the oven that dark and the texture was extremely cakey instead of “cookie” like. Any tips ? 🙂
I’d recommend starting to check them around 12 minutes at 375°F. Every oven is a little different, and 16 minutes may have been too long. The cakey texture could be from too much flour, so make sure to fluff your flour before gently spooning it into your measuring cup and leveling it off without packing it down. Also, be careful not to overmix the dough.