FROM MY FARMSTAND KITCHEN TO YOURS

Homemade Toffee

By Kelli Bowman

Jump to recipe

This rich, buttery toffee is perfectly crisp with deep caramelized flavor from brown sugar. Finished with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt, it’s an irresistible sweet-and-salty treat that’s perfect for gifting or snacking.

Loading recipe…

Questions & Comments

  1. Hi Kelli- (your name is spelled the same as my daughters! Your mother and I didn’t think about the fact that you’d have to spell it for everyone every time 😜, but worth it, I hope. It has a cute factor!). Anyhow, is this topic recipe the same you add to your chocolate chip toffee cookies but obviously you just don’t add the chocolate coating to this or do you have a separate toffee bits recipe? Thx- Janie

    1. I’ve made some changes to my toffee recipe over time, so some of my older videos may show a different version. The recipe currently posted on my website is the most up-to-date version I use!

  2. Can you freeze the toffee chocolate chip cookie dough recipe ? Didn’t know how the toffee holds up in the freezer. I just finished making the brown butter and the toffee to make your chocolate chip toffee recipe. Love your videos and all of your help.

    1. Yes, it should work! I’d recommend chilling the dough for 24 hours first, then scooping and freezing in an airtight container. You can bake straight from frozen, adding a few extra minutes if needed.

  3. how do you get your pieces so small? I have to tell you that you just absolutely won me over-i have watched your reels for sometime and I am just always reluctant to “follow” or put my email address in to get tips and such-but i just keep watching you and i love everything you do!! So much of what you do is how i like to do things and you just totally won me over with your personality and recipes and just being genuine!! Thank you!!

    1. That truly means a lot to me! Once my toffee has completely cooled and hardened, I break it into smaller pieces. You can also put it in a bag and gently tap it with a rolling pin to get those smaller bits.

  4. I tried your toffee today, for the first time, and it is delicious! I did add a little splash of vanilla because everything tastes better with vanilla! However, had two thermometers break, while in the process, so I had to use your visual cues…..but it turned out more like caramel! I am going to grt a new thermometer, but how do I know definitely that it’s the correct temperature?

    1. I’m so glad you enjoyed it! If it turned out more like caramel, it likely didn’t reach a high enough temperature. You’re aiming for 300°F (hard crack stage). I’d recommend testing your new thermometer in boiling water first to make sure it’s reading accurately!

  5. I have made your toffee chocolate chip cookies, and they are a hit! When it comes to making the toffee is there a reason why the butter seems to separate a little when the toffee is cooking and when it is poured out to cool?

    1. I’m so glad the cookies were a hit! Butter separation can happen if the heat is too high or the mixture heats unevenly. Try using a heavy-bottomed saucepan, keeping the heat a little lower, and stirring consistently to help everything stay together!

    2. I’m so glad the cookies were a hit! Butter can separate if the heat is too high or the mixture heats unevenly. Try using a heavy-bottomed saucepan, keeping the heat steady, and stirring regularly. If it’s separating after pouring, it may not have fully emulsified while cooking.

    1. It sounds like the toffee didn’t quite reach 300°F. You can try gently reheating it in a saucepan until it reaches the hard crack stage, but the texture may not turn out quite the same. I’d recommend using a candy thermometer for the best results!

      1. Thank you for your advice. I was second guessing my self i thought it needed a bit more time but was just worried it would burn…. 🤦🏽‍♀️😪

      2. Mine did the same last night (I was too impatient). Today I made a fresh batch and cooked it correctly. Then I put the first batch back into a pot and heated it up again…it wasn’t looking good for a while, but then it started coming together and finally reached hard crack stage…so far it looks and feels the same as the new batch!

  6. When I tried this recipie and put the Toffee to cool on the parchment paper… the butter started separating. Why and is there anything I can do to stop that?

    1. Butter separation usually happens when the mixture gets too hot or heats unevenly. Try using a heavy-bottomed saucepan, keeping the heat steady, and stirring consistently. Unfortunately, once it separates after pouring, it’s difficult to fix!

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Comments are reviewed before appearing on the site. Required fields are marked *.

Search recipes, baking tips, and farmstand stories.